Cast

June Muldoon: Laretta Davis

Tiny Wingfield (singer): Aubrey Winter

Rebecca Muldoon (mother): Emalee Leth

Maggie (elder): Tesla Landers

Hazel (farmer): Trasa Klein

Belva Collins (wife): Bentleigh Dugan

Crutch Collins (husband): Thayer Davis

Pastor Phineas Wingfield (preacher): Ethan Lobner

Dr Galen P Gray: William Pokorny

Prudence Belleweather (townsperson): Paige Berst

Rufus Prindle (townsperson): Raynea Pokorny

Lorelai Gibbons (townsperson): Alexa Gonzalez

Cast

Jenny the Lifeguard: Grace Reinsch

Pete the Lifeguard: Jameson Weiss

Brady the Head LIfeguard: Carson McDonald

Timmy the Head Lifeguard Trainee: Jaxon McDonald

Tina the Head Lifeguard Trainee: Angelica Garcia

Honey the Lifeguard: Harley Stutzman

Ginger the Lifeguard: Kayleigh Betka

Frankie the Lifeguard: Brayton Clark

Dougie the Lifeguard: Brandon Kiehl

Dispatch Dan the Lifeguard: Dylan Gonnerman

The Mayor of Shark's Island: Camille Chambers

Ernie, The Town Punk: Landyn Schade

Gertie, The Town Emo: Jaelynn Bourke

Brady's Absentee Mother: Antonia Boschult

Old Mrs. Jacobs: Krynne Hunzeker

Billy Joe, the Hillbilly Pa: Ethyn Schade

Loretta, the Hillbilly Ma: Claire Brugger

Pearlie Rose, the Hillbilly Beauty Queen: Leah Dawson

Bubba, the Hillbilly Little Brother: Jaxon Strope

Buck, The Hillbilly Twin Brother: Colby Yates

Bonnie, The Hillbilly Twin Sister: Kynnedy Bristol

The Bartender Wench: Krynne Hunzeker

Captain Ishmael: Joaquin Rojas

Sailor Sammie (The Laugher): Adley Cheek

Sailor Harry (The Pegged Leg One): Mason Fifield

Sailor Kermit (The Drunk One): Cole Sedlacek

Sailor Jerry (The Pipe Smoker): Carter Mierau

Sailor Mary (The Naughty One): Klaire Rasmussen

Keyboard: Lillian Miller

Keyboard: Lily Parker

Cast

Buddy Layman: Tyler Tegtmeier

Jennie Mae Layman: Larkyn Vlcek

Ferris Layman: Luke Hunzeker

CC Showers: Cael Johnson

Norma Henshaw (Dry goods owner): Abby Dietrich

Darlene Henshaw: Haylee Plager

Goldie Short(Cafe owner): Kailey Hartman

Basil Bennet: Gauge Schuetz

Luella Bennet: Layla Fetherkile

Melvin Wilder: Dylan Layne

Dewey Maples: Justin Baehr

Sarah Layman (ghost): Shayla Puhalla

Daisy (Darlene's friend): Ashlyn Puhalla

Marge (older aunt of Lisa): Isabella Seitz

Delores (smart and plucky townswoman): Emalyse Gottula

Gail (older townswoman): Adelyn Sisco

Lisa (younger girl): Emily Koster

Joyce (younger girl): Tiffany Sampont

Hank (well digger): Aiden Tozer

Larry (well digger): Braydon Frakes

Bill (well digger): Jordan Wernimont

Henry (well digger): Russell Weeks

Dave (well digger): Kailyn Jensen

Cast

Kat Strange: Macradee Lantis

Darcy Strange: Tristin Fleharty

Madame Duncan: Addison Ardval

Miss Beth: Eliana Dyer

Miss Duffy: Bryer Brown

Miss Bonnie: Maleah Vasquez

Hattie: Marley Reeves

Betsy: Leah Harper

Malcolm: Max Buscher

Dusty: Isaac Sinsel

Levey: Memphis Goodwin

Mister Fife: Tristan Woolf

Cowboy: Easton Dancer

Cowboy: Jack Wallace

Cowboy: Jack Meyer

Cowboy: Zayn Green

Cowboy: Kale Martinez

Cast

Freddie: Braydon Hoesing

Johnny: Rogan Hoesing

Mick: Gaven Nipp

Rich: Jaxson Wingert

Officer Burt: Luke Woockman

Mother Superior: Ainsley Dawson

Sister Mary Catherine: Taylor Dawson

Sister Agnes: Noel Kumm

Sister Josephine: Carlie Kleinschmit

Blind Sister Cecilia: Emmie Brazel

Father Andrew: Alijah Nelson

Brother Thomas: Brady Kristensen

Brother Philip: Ashton Baue

Mrs. Riddley: Tierney Alexander

Nuns: Mackenzie Suhr

Nuns: Elle Brazel

Nuns: Molly Aitken

Nuns: Kenley Anderson

Nuns: Kennedy Gillilan

Nuns: Reagan Gillilan

Nuns: Mya VanWinkle

Nuns: Kendra Kleinschmit

Nuns: Isabelle Seagren

Nuns: Hailey Smith

Nuns: Jaidynn Timmerman

Police Officers: Lincoln Thorell

Police Officers: Ryan Kleinschmit

Police Officers: Rudd Carlson

Police Officers: Hallie Kumm

Police Officers: Brent Kristensen

Police Officers: Remington Schwindt

Scraggly Children: Brent Kristensen

Scraggly Children: Mya VanWinkle

Scraggly Children: Kendra Kleinschmit

Scraggly Children: Isabelle Seagren

Scraggly Children: Elle Brazel

Scraggly Children: Jaidynn Timmerman

Cast

Narrator: Brandon Wagner

Billy Gilmore: Cooper Woollen

Peter Neigum: Kaden Woollen

Mrs. McGill: Kamryn Russell

Miss Blake: Taylor Ingram

Thomas Boyd: Brett Woollen

Grace: Chloe Johnson

Jenny: Parker Woollen

Laura: Madison Sheen

Mr. McGill: Cody Schriner

Father Hannah: Alexander Klatt-Terabelian